Short Sale Or Foreclosure? Which Is Better?

The preceding article, Unable To Keep Your Bradley Beach Home? Here Is What’s Next, explained the procedures for short sales and foreclosures. In this installment the two will be compared in terms of ramifications and consequences. Of greatest concern to the owner of Jersey Shore real estate who is losing his/her home are the effects on credit ratings and future loan availability. Those facing such a loss, however, should also take into consideration security clearance, employment, taxes, and deficiency judgments. The last two will be discussed in the next issue.


Short sale:

  • Only late payments on the mortgage of Jersey Shore real estate will be reflected. After the sale, the mortgage will be reported as paid or settled.
  • If all other payments are being made, the credit score could drop by as little as 50 points. Note that it is the late payments, not the short sale, that adversely affects the score.
  • The short sale is not recorded in the credit history.


  • Can affect the credit score from 250-300+ points for over 3 years.
  • Will remain on the credit history for 10+ years.


Short sale:

  • The homeowner or investor in Jersey Shore real estate whose payments were in default will be eligible for a Fannie Mae mortgage after 2 years.
  • In some cases Fannie Mae allows a non-defaulting seller to immediately apply for a new mortgage.
  • FHA guidelines say that after a short sale a seller who is current in payments may qualify immediately. However, in reality many lenders are reluctant to approve another loan at a reasonable interest rate until 2 years has elapsed.


  • Fannie Mae will not acknowledge homeowner eligibility for 5 years. For investors the waiting period is 7 years.
  • On any future loan applications an owner whose property has been foreclosed must disclose this fact in Section VIII. Such a declaration can have a negative effect on the interest rate offered.


Short sale:

  • Generally has no impact on the clearance.


  • In almost all cases a foreclosure provides cause for the termination of both the security clearance and the position.


Short sale:

  • Does not present any challenge to present or future employment.


  • May have negative impact of employees in sensitive positions.
  • Is often detrimental in any future hiring process.

About Patrick Parker Realty

Patrick Parker Realty, an independent boutique brokerage located in the heart of Bradley Beach is your local market leader. We understand the demands of a changing real estate market and avail ourselves of the latest industry information and tools to ensure excellent results. Our Commitment to You Our seasoned Real Estate Agents are committed to providing all of our clients, from first time sellers to veteran real estate investors, quality and friendly service. We walk you through every step of the sale process offering the guidance, feedback, and expertise needed to ensure your complete satisfaction.
This entry was posted in bradley beach real estate, Financing, jersey shore real estate, Sellers and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Short Sale Or Foreclosure? Which Is Better?

  1. Pingback: Distressed Properties and What They Mean to You | New Jersey Real Estate Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s